Botswana Defence Force, N.C. Guard Legal Experts Conduct Joint Mock Courts-Martial during Workshop

Legal experts from the North Carolina National Guard and Botswana Defence Force (BDF) held their first joint mock courts-martial as part of a trial advocacy workshop in Gaborone, Botswana August 15-19, 2011. <br /> <br />The event, coordinated



By Captain Adam Blocker North Carolina National Guard Public Affairs GABORONE, Botswana Aug 22, 2011
Legal experts from the North Carolina National Guard and Botswana Defence Force (BDF) held their first joint mock courts-martial as part of a trial advocacy workshop in Gaborone, Botswana August 15-19, 2011. The event, coordinated through the National Guard State Partnership Program and U.S. Africa Command, allowed American and Batswana military members to share legal concepts and frameworks within military justice, to understand different approaches and procedures in trial tactics, and to advance the relationship between the U.S. military and BDG. "[I'm] impressed with [the BDF's] advanced justice system and their enthusiasm to learn ours," said Major Alex Mendaloff III, defense counsel, N.C. National Guard trial defense service. The BDF Act, the law that applies to the Botswana military, and the Botswana civilian legal systems have several key differences from the U.S. justice system. For instance, Botswana doesn't permit plea bargaining; doesn't offer court-appointed attorneys, except in capital cases; and doesn't have a Trial Defense Service, a familiar concept with the U.S. Army. The BDF attorneys were interested in this idea and were briefed on the history of the 30 year old concept. Another primary difference between the U.S. and Botswana military is that the BDF only permits women in the Officerrâ?s Corps. Staff Sergeant Kristian Hall, senior paralegal noncommissioned officer and sexual assault response coordinator for the N.C. National Guard, briefed the BDF judge advocates about the role of the advocate in the courts-martial process and he fielded numerous pointed questions and hypothetical problem sets. The presentations and exchanges during the workshop proved to be a valuable experience for both parties as they prepared for a mock courts-martial presentation for students of the BDF Staff College, who served as members of the jury. â?This was a very good exchange of information â? as the BDF identified items that are issues with [the U.S. military],,â? said Lieutenant Colonel Graham Green, chief of Military Justice for the N.C. National Guard. After a full day of bilateral instructional and introductory legal briefings, the staff from both the N.C. Guard Judge Advocate General (JAG) Corps and the BDF JAG Corps met to begin preparations for full scale mock courts-martial. Mock Courts-Martial â?The trial is the crucible to determine the truth,,â? said Green at the start of the event. BDF Judge Advocates and paralegals took the lead as the prosecution and defense teams, as well as serving in roles as the accused, victim investigator and other witnesses, while staff college students served as the jury. â?I am looking forward to serving as a prosecutor for this court-martial, demonstrating our professionalism to our future commanders, learning from our partners and sharing our approach,,â? said 1st Lieutenant Tshepo Gaubotsane, the newest BDF judge advocate officer, prior to the start of the trial. The mock courts-martial featured introductory presentations from both BDF and N.C. National Guard judge advocates, examination and cross-examination conducted by the BDF judge advocates (with NCNG JAs on the prosecution and defense teams), questions from the students, opening and closing statements, and ultimately deliberation on the evidence. During the preparations, Green, who was also the lead trial counsel in the mock courts-martial, suggested to his BDF colleagues that "you have to find that prosecutor in the jury room who will stand up and say, 'this is not right,'" and this is exactly what the BDF judge advocates did. The arguments on both sides of the court-room aisle were executed with articulate precision. The scenario allowed BDF Staff Judge Advocate Major Ronald Kgomela and Colonel Richard Fay, N.C. National Guard staff judge advocate, to periodically call an administrative pause to the proceedings. This presented an opportunity to further explain a concept to the future commanding officers or to explain legal terminology used by both sides. After the closing arguments, the 33-member panel was divided into three separate syndicates or juries in order to give all of the officers an opportunity to act as a panel member. Three separate juries produced three entirely different verdicts against the "accused." They ranged from "guilty on all counts" to "not guilty" for the majority of the offenses. In response to the wide variety of verdicts, N.C. National Guard Trial Defense Services Chief Major Alexander Mendaloff III said "This is exactly the way it goes â? there is no rhyme or reason with juries, but they make quality decisions." With three full days of intense preparation, trial and deliberations, the bilateral mock courts-martial was deemed a great success by the participants and the BDF leadership. "I learned a lot from the direct and cross examination from both the defense and the prosecution and â? how [ our U.S. counterparts ] were in control the whole time" said BDF Major Ronald Kgomela. "We are a very young department that lacks in experience in personnel," said Kelipi. "The more we can learn from others â? the more we can improve." Fay, who has worked for the past two years to develop and nurture the exchange of ideas and shared learning with the BDF Legal directorate, said the workshop has served as another step in advancing U.S.-Botswana relations and partnership between each countries militaries.
More in Media Room
Joint Statement from the U.S. Department of Defense and the Department of National Defense of the Republic of Niger
The effective cooperation and communication between the U.S. and Nigerien armed forces ensured that this turnover was finished ahead of schedule and without any complications.
Read more
"Stronger Together": U.S. and Congolese Bands Unite for Joint Tour in Brazzaville and Pointe-Noire
This initiative marks the 64th anniversary of diplomatic relations between the United States and the Republic of the Congo, highlighting both nations' commitment to peace, cultural exchange, and mutual understanding.
Read more
United States turns over C-130H to Botswana Defence Force
U.S. Ambassador Howard A. Van Vranken, U.S. Ambassador to Botswana, and U.S. Marine Corps, Gen. Michael Langley, Commander, U.S. Africa Command, participated in the official transfer of a former U.S. military C-130 Hercules aircraft to the Botswana Defence Force in a significant step towards enhancing Botswana's defense capabilities.
Read more
More in Media Room
Joint Statement from the U.S. Department of Defense and the Department of National Defense of the Republic of Niger
The effective cooperation and communication between the U.S. and Nigerien armed forces ensured that this turnover was finished ahead of schedule and without any complications.
Read more
"Stronger Together": U.S. and Congolese Bands Unite for Joint Tour in Brazzaville and Pointe-Noire
This initiative marks the 64th anniversary of diplomatic relations between the United States and the Republic of the Congo, highlighting both nations' commitment to peace, cultural exchange, and mutual understanding.
Read more
United States turns over C-130H to Botswana Defence Force
U.S. Ambassador Howard A. Van Vranken, U.S. Ambassador to Botswana, and U.S. Marine Corps, Gen. Michael Langley, Commander, U.S. Africa Command, participated in the official transfer of a former U.S. military C-130 Hercules aircraft to the Botswana Defence Force in a significant step towards enhancing Botswana's defense capabilities.
Read more
More in Media Room
Joint Statement from the U.S. Department of Defense and the Department of National Defense of the Republic of Niger
The effective cooperation and communication between the U.S. and Nigerien armed forces ensured that this turnover was finished ahead of schedule and without any complications.
Read more
"Stronger Together": U.S. and Congolese Bands Unite for Joint Tour in Brazzaville and Pointe-Noire
This initiative marks the 64th anniversary of diplomatic relations between the United States and the Republic of the Congo, highlighting both nations' commitment to peace, cultural exchange, and mutual understanding.
Read more
United States turns over C-130H to Botswana Defence Force
U.S. Ambassador Howard A. Van Vranken, U.S. Ambassador to Botswana, and U.S. Marine Corps, Gen. Michael Langley, Commander, U.S. Africa Command, participated in the official transfer of a former U.S. military C-130 Hercules aircraft to the Botswana Defence Force in a significant step towards enhancing Botswana's defense capabilities.
Read more